Evolution of a Blog

This blog has evolved as I have as a maker. It starts at the beginning of my journey where I began to re-tread my tires in the useful lore of micro electronics and the open-source software that can drive them. While building solutions around micro-electronics are still an occasional topic my more recent focus has been on the 3D Printing side of making.

Friday, January 8, 2016

Summary of Resolution Differences for Tank Printing

Sherman V's printed at 0.15 and 0.1mm layer height (respectively) using a normal 0.4mm nozzle

Tiger II printed at a very, very high resolution using a 0.25mm nozzle and a layer height of 0.08mm.


The above print took 13:10 Hours!

For a normal nozzle and at different resolutions this would be:
9:47 for 0.08mm
7:59 for 0.1mm
5:55 for 0.15mm

This is pulled from another post earlier on this blog ... Here are the test prints that more clearly show the differences in resolution (layer height).

0.1mm

0.15mm

0.2mm

0.25mm

Other posts in the "tank" series (oldest to newest): 

Second Order was for a Tank!
Tanks, Tanks, and More Tanks!
Some More Tanks
Removing Support from a Tank Print
Tired of Tanks Yet?
Visual impact of Resolution (Layer Height) and Speed

Saturday, January 2, 2016

Painting Tanks - First Blood

First it was printing tanks.  Lots of them.  Then it was designing and printing bling for tanks.  Lots of bling.  Still doing that by the way.  Then it was designing a bridge for tanks.  Am rather happy with that bridge also, by the way.  Now it is painting tanks ... and as covered in the last post,  dioramas in which to house them!

The first two tanks, the Panther G and the T-34, were painted by Prepared for War.  I had tried to paint a Sherman but had given up on the job.  On seeing these two demonstrations of what a little tank can look like, I decided to try my hand again.  I do think that David, at Prepared for War, might have had to spend a little more time on my models than he expected.  First, because I don't think that I did too good a job of cleanup, and second as the prints that I sent him were not as good as later prints that I have done (the Tiger in particular).

The last model shown below is not 3D Printed but is a regular injection molded model.  There is not a Stug available to print and paint as a direct comparison so I have ordered a King Tiger model to contrast against the one shown below.

Finally, I am working on another diorama (the first one featured a Bailey Bridge), this time an urban setting, that will feature a great deal more printed content.  The King Tiger will play the key role in that diorama.







Now leaving the professionally painted tanks behind we come to the fourth tank that I actually printed myself.  The first was the Sherman that I gave up on doing.  The second was a Panther G that I learned from but binned.  The third was pretty much exactly as below but was gifted.  This is a Cromwell IV and as you can see features some 3D Printed bling as well.




King Tiger printed with a 0.25mm nozzle, a layer height of 0.08mm, and at a pretty slow speed.  This is a high quality print and took over ten hours to complete!  I am happy with the result and with my paint job though I have not finished yet...as in it needs some aging.  Yes the number on the tank is bogus and will get changed!



Below is the Open Fire StuG G injection molded kit.  I did a reasonably good job of assembly and painting.  Very happy with my painting of the details.   Not so happy with the camo job which was my attempt at soft edged style using a brush as I don't have an airbrush (yet).  Also not sure about the tone of the paint compared to the Tiger.   I thought that I had done them the same but now don't remember.  Need to do two models at the same time and see what the differences really are.




There is no doubt that the quality of the injection molded model is better than my best print:
  • Even at 0.08mm resolution you can still make out extrusion lines.  Injection molded plastic parts are going to be a lot nicer than extruded parts.  Other 3D Printing technologies would or will address this (but not in my man cave).
  • While M_Bergman does a fantastic job of his models the details from areas like the road wheels on the StuG are better as a result of the injection molding process versus 3D Printing.
  • Other details on the StuG are also improved by the kit nature of the build.  Note that some of these things can easily be done on printed models (addition of bling).
I guess the question is one that the war gamer is going to have to answer.   Is the quality good enough?  Assuming someone has their own printer, assuming they have plenty of time to print tanks, and discounting capital costs for the printer, the King Tiger cost me 53p to print using mid-grade plastic.  It probably took the same amount of time for cleanup, removing support material and other artifacts of the print process, as assembly of an extruded model.  I have not done a side by side comparison but I assume that painting times will be about the same.

Those are some big assumptions but the presence of 3D Printers will be growing and I suspect that more and more armies will be marching as prints rather than extrusions.


Monday, December 14, 2015

Intersection of Modeling and 3D Printing

My introduction to printing tanks, and then bling for tanks, was a natural progression towards further work that intersects modeling with 3D Printing.  As a youngster I assembled the standard plastic models, then as an adult I did a couple more advanced models and spent some time flying R/C aircraft.  Now, with 3D Printers in hand, I am trying my luck again!

My first challenge was to acquire and master the technology that enables the printing of tiny little things.  This meant a printer upgrade that I have discussed elsewhere on this blog.  This upgrade gives me the ability to print some really tiny little things ... obviously important when working at 1:100 scale!

I designed a pretty wide selection of "bling" for Flames of War gamers capitalizing on my printers ability to handle the size and detail.  All of what I have done are on Thingiverse in the public domain (the Creative Commons - Attribution - Non-Commercial license).
The are also available for purchase on eBay with 50% of all proceeds going to the MS Society.

My latest, and largest, design is that of a model of the famous Bailey Bridge of World War II.  I discuss it in several posts starting here.

The next challenge was to gain the skill, and patience, to paint tiny details.  I still have a ways to go given where I am versus where other folks are in this specialty!    My first couple of
attempts were truly pathetic but I did improve to the point where I am not embarrassed by my work!

All of the above now comes together in a small diorama as shown to the right.  This is a mash-up of multiple 3D prints including:

  • The Bailey Bridge that I mentioned above but decorated for war!
  • Terrain started as a print with a rough cutout of the landscape.  I then plastered it with Smooth Finish Wall Filler for texture.
  • The tank is also a 3D Print though certainly not from one of my models. The model is from the work of M_Bergman though I did do the painting!
  • The tank is also sporting some bling printed from my collection of bits and bobs.
  • The retaining walls for the ramps leading onto the bridges are 3D Prints as are the telephone poles.

I am not sure how much impact 3D Printing is having on modeling as of yet.  Printers are coming down in price but they are not cheap and they can be a pain in the ass to operate.  On top of that is the level of proficiency required to create things beyond simple shapes.  I am confident that printer costs will continue to fall and that reliability and ease of use will continue to improve.  I am less confident that "easy" design tools will play a role in bringing 3D Printing to the masses.

Sunday, December 6, 2015

Bailey Bridge Model Kits for Sale!

Below is a Bailey Bridge Kit consisting of three sections, or 30 full scale feet, integrated into a mini-diorama (which is still a bit of a work in progress). 

Four versions of this kit are listed on eBay in an auction format.  









I am doing this as an auction to assess interest and to help come to a price point for future sales.  As usual 50% of proceeds go to benefit the MS Society.

Build instructions are here on Instructables.  The model files are in the public domain here on Thingiverse under a Creative Commons - Attribution - Non-Commercial license.  Background on this project is here on this blog.


Thursday, November 19, 2015

Beta Build for the 1:100 Scale Bailey Bridge Model


Three people from the Flames of War group on Facebook have volunteered to do a test build of the 1:100 scale version of the Bailey Bridge.  Their kits have been printed and are going into the post today.

Obviously I want feedback on the Assembly Instructions on Instructables and general feedback on the model but I also wanted to call attention to the following area in particular:

  • In step 3 of the instructions I mention cleaning of the parts.  The four panels that you need have some particularly bad oozing.  This is a new issue as the part used to print cleanly.  Rather than wait while I try to figure it out I have sent you the kit but have also sent spare panels so you can experiment with cleaning with a little less risk than if you only have four.  These spares would not be the case for a normal kit.  There are also a number of spares for the Rakers and Bracing Frames.  I expect the normal kit would have one spare of each,  Anyway, the feedback that I am wanting is to know how the cleanup went.
  • Each of you has asked for a ramps set.  I would be interested in knowing what you did with this part of the kit as I don't have the game board to marry up the bridge so was winging it as to what would be needed!  Obviously interested in whatever changes you suggest!
Thanks again for the help.  If you could use the comments section below for feedback it would be helpful for sharing between yourselves and as a record for future builders!

Four Flavors of a Bailey Bridge

A full scale Bailey Bridge could be (and still is!) built in a variety of configurations depending on design needs all using the same basic parts.  Giant erector set for bridges.  My 1:100 scale kit is not quite so flexible given some of the compromises that scale and expediency forced on me.  That said I do have the following four types covered (at least in the full source which will be up on Thingiverse soon)!
Single-Single
Double-Single
Triple-Single
Triple-Double
Somewhat obviously from looking at the above pictures the first descriptor is the number of panels used on each side and the second the number of levels!  The more the longer and the more weight can be supported.   There is a field manual that engineers use to determine what configuration is needed.  Once that is determined the manual tells the builders exactly what parts will be needed.  Really impressive.

Monday, November 16, 2015

Bailey Bridge 1:100 Scale Model Test Builders Wanted

I am looking for a couple folks to do a beta test build of my new 1:100 scale Bailey Bridge model per this Instructable:



I would like one of these folks to be located in the UK for speed of getting them the model. Regardless of where you live I will pay for the postage.

I only ask that you can:
  1. Assemble the model as soon as possible (it is not a long build)
  2. Provide some constructive feedback on the model and the build process / instructions
  3. Take some pictures and share them with me.
As soon as I can get a second party test assembly I will put all the source files out on Thingiverse and start offering them as part of my Bling Collection.  

Here are the options available
Two or Three Sections (20 or 30 full scale feet)

Ramp or No Ramp

55mm (only the road showing!) or Scale Width (game play versus diorama)
If you are interested please message me on FB and I will get the first UK person and the second UK or first non-UK person a model kit of their choice.

If you are actually still reading this!!! and you are building a diorama that would need a longer scale version of this kit, or if you wanted that diorama to show one under construction, please message me. I would love to see a copy in a nice diorama.